When students are first taught how to write essays, teachers instruct them to organize their thoughts to help them write a structured paper. Students only learn two different methods: the bubble chart and the outline. But which method is best? I’m glad you asked.
This is an epic face-off between linear thinkers and abstract thinkers. Let’s meet our competitors.
In the first corner we have the bubble chart. The bubble chart allows students to be creative with ideas by exploring the many different sub topics of an essay and how they interact with each other. A type of free writing technique (that lets writers get all of their ideas out where they can then decide what they want to use in their paper. Although, the bubble chart lacks rigid structure, its strength is organized chaos.
In the second corner we have the outline. The outline allows writers to follow a more structured path. The outline follows a more linear train of thought and forces the writer to explore and develop the main subtopics before delving into the nuances. This sounds pretty organized and thorough right? We agree, but some would say this is detrimental to a writers’ creativity.
We’ve got a wild card here: the word vomit. Just when you were ready to choose between the bubble chart and the outline, a third candidate jumped into the ring. The “word vomit” writing style is not organized at all. It allows for a writer to just dive right into the essay without so much as a care to the prose’s finite organization. Sometimes the best way to write is to just develop the meat, and then connect the key concepts using the bones later. Remember, the choice to not organize is still a choice.
Students may benefit from using an outline for long research papers while bubble charts may be more helpful for those 1-2 page creative essays. The free for all type of essay that doesn’t require any organization is also perfect for conversational styles of writing.
So, which candidate won in this epic battle of organizational proportions? Sorry to be anticlimactic, but all of them win. In the end it is up to the writer as to what method they choose: the more structured outline, the free flowing bubble chart, or the choice to not organize at all.
Which method do you use?

